Did reverse swing decide the 2017/18 Ashes?

After a brief lull, Cameron Bancroft’s explosive intervention dropped a bomb onto the re-hashing of the Sandpapergate scandal.

The previous events now seem like barely audible chatter compared to Bancroft’s chronicle. With the sheer number of contradictory accounts now stacking up against his own, the world waits for what Pat Cummins’ next move will be. Despite a brief lull today with a holding statement from Cummins, nothing, and particularly not this, can stay quiet for long.

Nor should it. Khawaja’s got a book to sell, Bancroft has a burden he’s carried for eight years to offload, and Cummins has a reputation and a job to defend. All sides have enormous amounts, personally and professionally, resting on what comes next.

As an entirely self-centred England fan, however, the part of Bancroft’s statement which piqued my interest were the allegations of Australia tampering with the ball during the 2017/18 Ashes series. “I remember during my first Test match being instructed, along with other members of the team, to push the quarter seam of the ball together after the team took a wicket,” wrote Bancroft of that series.

These aren’t new allegations. Khawaja references that series in his book, the one that started all of this, . Although he goes into more detail about exactly when Australia tried to alter the condition of the ball in that series. “But we – and I say ‘we’ because we were a team, whether you did the deed or not – had worked out that if we raised the flaps up on the quarter seam on that ball, it was almost like it had a rudder on it and it’d start reverse swinging,” he wrote.

There have been questions about Australia’s methods to move the ball in that series ever since the scandal first erupted in South Africa. “Look at the Ashes series we’ve just played,” said Stuart Broad in a press conference during England’s series in New Zealand in the days after Sandpapergate. “Look through all of those Test matches and they reverse swing the ball sometimes in conditions you wouldn’t expect the ball to reverse. So I don’t understand why they’ve changed their method for this one game?”

While 2017/18 is one of the less egregiously disastrous Ashes tours England have been on over the last 15 years – arguably their best performance in that time period, a terrifying thought. But if Khawaja and Bancroft’s assertions are correct, there are further mitigating factors behind England’s 4-0 loss. If England were having to deal with an illegally chewed-up ball, their task was surely insurmountable.

The hardest part of the allegations is that we’ll likely never know the truth. Too many people would have to admit to lying, and perhaps those who are lying have lied for so long they now genuinely believe they’re telling the truth. However, let’s try and set out some facts in these murky waters – did reverse swing give Australia the upper hand in the 2017/18 Ashes?

The allegations

In , Khawaja has detailed two instances where reverse swing resulting from tampering with the ball tipped the game in their favour.

The first is Adelaide, the day-night Test, which Australia won by 120 runs. England were barely in that game, although they clung on to brief hope at points. They bowled Australia out for 138 in the second innings, limiting their fourth-inning requirement to a cool 354. They got nowhere near, as Mitchell Starc ripped through them, taking 5-88.

“We were reverse swinging it late on day five,” writes Khawaja in , referencing the third Test in Perth. “Actually, we were reverse swinging the ball the game before too [in Adelaide] – except it was much tougher, because it was the pink ball.”

Looking back at the final innings of that Test, if Australia tampered with the ball then they didn’t do it very well. The first two wickets on that day, with a 60-over old ball, fell to Josh Hazlewood, who nipped out nightwatcher Chris Woakes and Joe Root with deliveries that held their line through to the keeper. The third of the six wickets Australia needed that day went to Nathan Lyon, before a new ball was taken. The first delivery with that ball from Starc genuinely swung to pin Craig Overton lbw - crucially, however, that swing clearly cannot have been generated by illegal actions so soon into a ball’s lifespan. Broad fell to Starc two overs later, and Jonny Bairstow chopped on two overs after that. Job done.

If we can conclude that none of England’s wickets fell because of reverse swing in that innings, then ball tampering likely didn’t swing the game in Australia’s favour. Even if Khawaja was referencing England’s first innings, only three deliveries can possibly have had a factor of reverse swing to them – i.e they were taken by a pacer bowler with an older ball. Of those, Dawid Malan got an inside edge on a ball that jagged back off the surface, Bairstow fell to a brilliant caught and bowled from Starc, and Chris Woakes also hit one back to the bowler.

It would be hard to say that reverse swing genuinely played a part in any of England’s dismissals in that Test. Quite simply, England were never in it, and Australia were far better. Shocker.

The other incident Khawaja mentions in the Sabr passage about the 2017/18 Ashes concerns a ball viewed 1.5 million times on Cricket Australia’s YouTube channel from Starc to James Vince in the third Test in Perth. “We won the game comprehensively by an innings . . . Starcy bowled that unforgettable ball to James Vince off the crack.”

There’s no mention there of ball tampering playing a part in that dismissal, as it would be hard to alter the ball so it’s magnetised to the cracks in the surface at the WACA. The ball was a snorter, but its movement came off the surface, not through the air. Had that ball been a reverse-swinging demon that bowled Vince when he was on 55*, he may have had grounds to sue for lost earnings from his practically non-existent Test career after that series. But, regardless of whether or not Australia were attempting to lift the seam of the ball to get it reversing in that Test, based on that delivery alone, Vince has no grounds to launch a case.

The context

Attempts by both sides to generate reverse swing in that series were well documented. In Melbourne, England managed to get the ball to start reversing early in Australia’s second innings. There was a flash point where TV commentators saw James Anderson using his fingernail on the ball, but it was a non-story which was easily explained as Anderson legitimately pushing down a loose bit of leather in front of the umpires.

England were, however, warned about throwing the ball into Bairstow behind the stumps on the bounce – a widely used tactic to scuff up the ball and get it reversing quicker. The desperation of both sides to get the ball reversing is not up for debate. Nor is whether tactics were used that both pushed the rules to their fullest extent and past them – we’ve got the footage from Cape Town for that. Equally, we have the footage from the fifth Ashes Test which seemingly shows Bancroft putting sugar in his pocket before going onto the field – does the sugar only need to be coating mints for it to be a problem?

As with what happened in South Africa, we’ll probably never know the full truth of the extent to which ball tampering was used in the 2017/18 Ashes. However, what we can be sure of is that, with a pristine ball or one that had been through a rotary grater, England were so much worse than Australia that it wouldn’t have mattered.

Follow Wisden for all cricket updates, including and more. Stay up to date with the .

Original source Did reverse swing decide the 2017/18 Ashes?

Back to home