
The International Court of Appeal has issued a statement in reaction to the allegations of bias made by Alpine executive director Flavio Briatore yesterday.
The ICA, which is independent of the FIA, ruled against Alpine and the governing body in a case brought by Red Bull and McLaren over a decision made in the Monaco Grand Prix three months ago. The court reinstated two penalties issued to Alpine driver Pierre Gasly which the Monaco stewards previously struck out. Gasly fell from third place to seventh in the classification as a result.Briatore suggested one of the four ICA judges involved in the decision, Filippo Marchino, favoured McLaren. In response the ICA defended the integrity of its selection process.
“The FIA Courts are aware of public comments questioning the independence and impartiality of the judges of the panel that decided Case ICA-2026-06-07-08-0,” it said in a statement issued by ICA president Laurent Anselmi, ICA vice-president Waltraud Wunsch, International Tribunal president Rui Botica Santos and vice-president Gerard Martin.
“The FIA Courts wish to make clear that the appointment and participation of the judges in that case, like for any other case, were conducted in accordance with the applicable FIA judicial procedures and usual practice, which are inspired by the highest standards like the IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in International Arbitration.
“All judges are elected by the FIA General Assemblies, some of them upon proposition of a group of at least five F1 teams in accordance with the FIA Statutes. They are all subject to the independence and confidentiality requirements contained in the FIA Judicial and Disciplinary Rules, make annual disclosures of interests to the FIA Compliance Officer, and sign a specific declaration of independence for each particular case in consideration of the issue at stake and the parties involved, which is served to the parties.”
The ICA pointed out all parties involved in the case, including Alpine, had the opportunity to raise any concerns they had over the selection of judges.
Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and
“At both the beginning and conclusion of the hearing, the parties were invited to raise any issue concerning the proceedings or the composition of the Court,” they said. “None did so.
“No objection was raised during the hearing concerning the manner in which the Court questioned the witness or conducted the proceedings.”
Marchino, a US-based lawyer, was one of four judges involved in the decision. Michael Grech presided over the hearing and Tomas Borec and Luigi Fumagalli were also appointed.
“The ICA emphasises the importance of constituting panels with judges from different cultural and geographical backgrounds,” the statement continued, “This helps ensure that the deliberations and discussions reflect a diversity of legal traditions, perspectives and approaches, further strengthening the fairness, independence, credibility of the process and access to a fair trial.
“A Court’s decision can leave room for various interpretations and comments as for its legal merits; that is fair and accepted by all the judges. The Court is confident in the soundness of the proceedings and the integrity of the judges. The FIA Courts remain committed to the independence and impartiality of their judges and to the integrity of the judicial process.”
Browse all Formula 1 articles