Alpine’s Briatore accuses Appeal Court judge of bias after losing Gasly case | Formula 1

Alpine executive consultant Flavio Briatore has accused a member of the Court of Appeal of bias after the team lost its third place in the Monaco Grand Prix.

Red Bull and McLaren successfully petitioned the appeal court to reinstate the two pit lane speeding penalties issued to Gasly during the race. This relegated him to seventh in the final classification, promoting Red Bull’s Isack Hadjar to third place and McLaren’s Oscar Piastri to fourth.

In the FIA press conference following the publication of the decision, Briatore accused one of the court members of bias in favour of McLaren. He claimed an organisation linked to the member received cars through McLaren Special Operations, part of the McLaren Group’s road car division.

“We accept the decision,” said Briatore. “But what is very strange was four judge in the panel, and one of the judge act like a prosecutor. For this, not big problem.

Pierre Gasly, Alpine, Monaco, 2026
“The problem is he’s very linked with the McLaren company because we have a nice picture of this guy at the speech for McLaren in 2018 in MSO Beverly Hills. Him have a foundation, it’s called One Drop Foundation, and McLaren gave two or three McLaren cars. And it was quite unfair one of the judges was linked with a team protesting us.”

Briatore confirmed he was referring to Filippo Marchino, one of the four ICA members, who serves on the board of the One Drop Foundation which promotes access to clean water. The foundation reportedly began winding down its operation last month.

McLaren team principal Andrea Stella called Briatore’s claims in today’s FIA press conference “insulting” and defended the governing body’s handling of the hearing.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and

“I find that this conference is going in this direction quite insulting for McLaren, for the reputation of a team that deserves a lot of respect,” he said. “If anybody makes these kind of allegations which seem quite serious, they are going to have to take the responsibility for what they are saying in a public forum.

Pierre Gasly, Alpine, Monaco, 2026
“The hearing, the whole International Court of Appeal was conducted to the highest standards and we should not question this phase like it’s been done.”

Marchino, who has been an FIA judge since 2024, is a US-based lawyer who specialises in cases involving serious personal injury, wrongful death and large class action lawsuits. He has also competed in rounds of the World Rally Championship.

Briatore continued his criticism of Marchino during the FIA press conference, calling his appointment “unfair.”

“The judge normally needs to be independent, completely,” he said. “And this judge, the name is kind of an Italian name, but he’s American, Filippo Marchino.

“Filippo Marchino is a judge, he was very nasty during the hearing, was acting as a prosecutor. And after, we found out what is the reason why so nasty, this guy. He is very linked with McLaren. This I notice.

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and

“So whatever Stella said, for the sport, for this, first I think someone, where you have the judgement, the judge needs to be independent. Not somebody doing the speech for McLaren and somebody using the McLaren car in the charity. This is the point.

“After that, the points one, one, three, two, four, five, I don’t care. I’m very surprised this guy have the link with McLaren.”

The judging panel for the ICA is appointed by its president, currently Laurent Anselmi. Marchino was one of four judges appointed alongside Michael Grech, who presided over the hearing, Tomas Borec and Luigi Fumagalli.

In ICA decisions involving F1 matters, the panel must include at least one judge elected on proposal of at least five competitors in the championship. All nominees are subject to a due diligence process performed by the FIA’s compliance officer. The nominated judges are then reviewed by a further panel which makes recommendations to the FIA’s Eligibility Assessment Committee.

Briatore has clashed with the FIA before. In 2009 the governing body attempted to ban him from motorsport for life over his involvement in the ‘Crashgate’ conspiracy while he was team principal of Renault. He later successfully challenged the decision in the French courts and returned to the team, now operating as Alpine.

Other F1 team bosses have previously been sanctioned by the FIA for criticising their officials. In 2021 former Red Bull team principal Christian Horner was given an official warning for describing a marshal as “rogue” for waving a yellow flag which led to Max Verstappen being penalised. Guenther Steiner, previously Haas’s team principal, was twice penalised for similar transgressions, including when he was fined for calling a steward “stupid” and “idiotic”.

Update: Court of Appeal issues defence to Briatore’s allegations of bias over Gasly decision

Advert | Become a RaceFans supporter and

Browse all Formula 1 articles

Original source Alpine’s Briatore accuses Appeal Court judge of bias after losing Gasly case | Formula 1

Back to home